(06-04-2015, 05:15 PM)Memenu Wrote: 3. So basically, what will she do when a band of adventurers is looming over Memenu with weapons?
This is actually a question I've thought about for a fair while. Chances are, such a fight will not only be inevitable, but will not be the only one. If it comes down to it, Memenu will fight. She'll say her piece and if their resolve is to attempt to send her back to the Aether still holds, she will defend herself like any "person" would.

Las Vegas Lore Panel Wrote:MCKF: The Lambs of Dalamud came after hearing this story and I thought “Yes, perfect!” We had this group that were the remnants of that story from thousands and thousands of years ago when everyone knew about Dalamud and what it was for, they saw them construct it and shoot it into space and knew they had the power to bring it back but then along came the calamity* and people forgot about it. The few people that remained passed it along to their children and the more that happened the more it got diluted. The core remained though that one day Dalamud might come back.

MCKF: So you had these crazy people thinking it was some kind of lesser god. Yeah everyone worships Menphina but it’s actually Dalamud, her hound is the one that protects her because she’s the one that’s weak and he’s only going to save the believers. It’s a cult, they’re not driven by reason and logic they’re driven by “That’s what Dad believed in, that’s what grandma believed in.”

(06-04-2015, 07:06 PM)LiadansWhisper Wrote:

(06-04-2015, 05:15 PM)Memenu Wrote: 3. So basically, what will she do when a band of adventurers is looming over Memenu with weapons?
This is actually a question I've thought about for a fair while. Chances are, such a fight will not only be inevitable, but will not be the only one. If it comes down to it, Memenu will fight. She'll say her piece and if their resolve is to attempt to send her back to the Aether still holds, she will defend herself like any "person" would.

I'm just curious as to what she could possibly say to convince anyone not to save the land itself from her existence?

(06-04-2015, 07:12 PM)Memenu Wrote: That there's far more important things to worry about than a Primal that's actively helping the adventurers do their job, not only destroying other Primals but crushing the Garleans among other things.

(06-04-2015, 07:17 PM)LiadansWhisper Wrote: Except she's destroying the planet by existing at all.  I mean, there are no ifs, ands, or buts about that - Primals strip the planet of aether and destroy the land when they are summoned.  Even Good King Moggle Mog and Ramuh (neither of whom are exactly "evil" by nature) had to go because they were destroying the planet.

Edited to Add: And wasn't that the issue with the Garleans in the first place?  The biggest fear at the time was less that the Garleans would march through and take over (though that was definitely a fear), and more that the Beast Tribes would, out of desperation, summon Primals...which were viewed as worse than an invasion by Garlemald.

Maybe I'm misremembering something right here...

(06-04-2015, 07:28 PM)Memenu Wrote:

(06-04-2015, 07:17 PM)LiadansWhisper Wrote: Except she's destroying the planet by existing at all.  I mean, there are no ifs, ands, or buts about that - Primals strip the planet of aether and destroy the land when they are summoned.  Even Good King Moggle Mog and Ramuh (neither of whom are exactly "evil" by nature) had to go because they were destroying the planet.

Edited to Add: And wasn't that the issue with the Garleans in the first place?  The biggest fear at the time was less that the Garleans would march through and take over (though that was definitely a fear), and more that the Beast Tribes would, out of desperation, summon Primals...which were viewed as worse than an invasion by Garlemald.

Maybe I'm misremembering something right here...

What I'm reading on the FF wiki is that Primals are a threat due to their never-ending want of followers, crystals and Aether to increase their power. If this is correct, Memenu is a "non-threat" which is both unique and...Strange. I'm looking more into it, because I'm only getting this from the Moggle Mog page.

(06-04-2015, 07:28 PM)Warren Castille Wrote: Keep in mind when discussing people's reactions: Roleplayers vary as much as anything else, so it's impossible to rationalize "Well, most people would feel X way about Y incident."

There's also the obvious caveat of the lalafell cult thing doing the summoning: So far we've seen summoning result in the entity being conjured on the spot. If your lalafell tribe is being held captive, there are some unanswered questions.

1) Why would Memenu leave those who summoned her in a jam to roam to Eorzea?

2) If they're not saved, and are still captured, why would they resummon her? She failed them the first time.

3) If somehow the summon didn't conjure Memenu to the summoners, how would they even know it worked? If she gets killed, how would they know to resummon her?

4) If they are saved, why would they resummon Memenu at all? Their plight is over.

(06-04-2015, 07:41 PM)Memenu Wrote:

(06-04-2015, 07:28 PM)Warren Castille Wrote: Keep in mind when discussing people's reactions: Roleplayers vary as much as anything else, so it's impossible to rationalize "Well, most people would feel X way about Y incident."

There's also the obvious caveat of the lalafell cult thing doing the summoning: So far we've seen summoning result in the entity being conjured on the spot. If your lalafell tribe is being held captive, there are some unanswered questions.

1) Why would Memenu leave those who summoned her in a jam to roam to Eorzea?

2) If they're not saved, and are still captured, why would they resummon her? She failed them the first time.

3) If somehow the summon didn't conjure Memenu to the summoners, how would they even know it worked? If she gets killed, how would they know to resummon her?

4) If they are saved, why would they resummon Memenu at all? Their plight is over.

1. Why would Memenu leave those who summoned her in a jam to roam Eorzea?
Not by choice, if the Garlean military found out, she'd probably be killed almost immediately, more so if Ultima was combat ready. Especially within Garlean lines.

2. If they're not saved, why would they resummon her if she failed them the first time?
Point number one, but they could've been re-deployed somewhere else or are in a location not yet visited by the players as of the events of 2.5.

3a. If somehow the summoning ritual didn't conjure Memenu to the summoners, how would they even know it worked?
They wouldn't, but as one of her followers used her own soul and body as the sacrifice, the summon had a perfect focal point.

3b. If she gets killed, how would they know to resummon her?
At this point, they most likely wouldn't. The amount of time and effort required to get the materiel needed would probably take too long to summon her again if it was needed, especially with the fall of the Castrums (or most of them) in Eorzea.


4. If they are saved, why would they resummon Memenu at all? Their plight is over.
Exactly; why would they? Perhaps to help others who are as misfortunate as they were during their time subjugated to Garlean prisoners. While not everyone needs a savior, the realm needs a hero, no matter how unlikely they may be.

-edit-
Nako'li, http://finalfantasy.wikia.com/wiki/Primal

" it is said that the flux of aether over Silvertear Falls has been disrupted and the whole land of Eorzea will slowly perish if this process isn't reversed."

Quote:Due to the presence of Primals in Eorzea and the massive amount of energy needed to summon them, it is said that the flux of aether over Silvertear Falls has been disrupted and the whole land of Eorzea will slowly perish if this process isn't reversed.

(06-04-2015, 07:48 PM)Edricane Wrote: You can play your character how you want, RP her how you want. But I'm sad to say she's walking lore bomb. Primals are destroyed as Liadan said, because they poison Hydaelyn. The reason the Garleans haven't amassed a massive force to attack Eorzea and rid of the primal problem, is because the primal problems in other places are greater, seeing the scions are snuffing out what primals pop up in Eorzea.

(06-04-2015, 07:28 PM)Memenu Wrote: What I'm reading on the FF wiki is that Primals are a threat due to their never-ending want of followers, crystals and Aether to increase their power. If this is correct, Memenu is a "non-threat" which is both unique and...Strange. I'm looking more into it, because I'm only getting this from the Moggle Mog page.

(06-04-2015, 09:57 PM)Reppu Wrote: I will note one more thing!

If she is being summoned by Lalafells under blight by Garleans... she would appear nearby them, no? And if so, would she not handle the problem there?

Basically, how do you excuse her wandering about/being in the Quicksand/etc etc? Primals are summoned where they are prayed for.

(06-04-2015, 10:16 PM)LiadansWhisper Wrote: Primals siphon aether from the land by existing.  It doesn't have to be conscious.  It's just how they work.  They can't maintain a form without doing so, and that is why they are such a problem.  Tempering is a secondary issue, and their love of crystals goes right back with their need to constantly consume aether to continue existing.

Someone feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, but I could swear this has been mentioned at least two or three times so far in this thread, and thus far you have never addressed it.  You keep ignoring that pesky, but important fact.